profile

Salamander Bay LLC

The chart says her average glucose was 117 to 137 ... Seriously?

Published about 4 hours ago • 1 min read

Hey Reader, Dr Karl here.

The chart says her average glucose was 117 to 137
Here's what happens when the formula meets the actual measurement.
​

There is a chart in every endocrinology office that converts your A1c
into an estimated average glucose. It is printed on lab reports.
It gets quoted back to patients as though it were a measurement.

A person with an A1c reading of 5.7 to 6.4,
that chart says your average glucose should be between 117 and 137 mg/dL.

My client's A1c was 5.7. Her fasting glucose was 92.
She was tracking her food and watching her glucose.
Her actual numbers were nowhere near 117, let alone 137.

Either the measurement is wrong or the conversion is wrong.
The conversion is wrong, for her.
It is a population average being applied to one person,
and it was built mostly on people whose A1c behaves the way the textbook says it should.

Look at her four years of these results: Glucose 108, 104, 101, 92.
​Straight down, year over year. A1c 5.3, 5.5, 5.7, 5.7.
Straight up, then flat at the line that gets you a diagnosis.

If A1c were a glucose test those two rows would move together. They moved apart.
Not noisily apart, but consistently apart, for four straight years.

This is the part that makes me careful about reference ranges generally.
​A range is a statement about a population. ​
​Your lab result is a statement about you. ​
Those are different kinds of claim, and the second one is the only one you live in.

A conversion chart is not a measurement.
If you want to know your average glucose, measure your glucose.

​Link to the video about this story.

~Dr. Karl Goldkamp~
Keto Naturopath

Link to our books

Become a client coaching ​

Salamander Bay LLC

Read more from Salamander Bay LLC

Hey Reader, Dr Karl here. A1c tracks glucose beautifully, in only one group of people. A1c tracks glucose tightly in insulin resistant people. In everyone else it barely tracks at all. Two groups. One line is steep. The other is almost flat.That is one sentence and it undoes most of what A1c gets used for. Glucose verses Hemoglobin A1c Red line is the insulin resistant group. Steep. As glucose rises, A1c rises with it, more or less the way the textbook promises. Green line is everyone else....

4 days ago • 1 min read

Hey Reader, Dr Karl here. A1c is not a glucose test. It is a protein test. It measures the percentage of your hemoglobin that has glucose stuck to it. Hemoglobin lives inside red blood cells. A1c has two inputs, not one: 1. how much glucose is in your blood, and 2. how long your red cells stay Nobody tells you about the second one. Here is a client. Four years of work. Fasting insulin down 65%, from 9.6 to 3.4. Glucose down 16 points, from 108 to 92. CRP down 87%, from 3.6 to 0.47. Eleven...

6 days ago • 1 min read

Hey Reader, Dr Karl here. Last time: her insulin, glucose, inflammation and weight all improved over four years, her CGM went flat, and her A1c went up to 5.7 and parked at the prediabetes line. Here is what A1c actually is, because almost nobody is told. A1c is not a glucose test. It is the percentage of your hemoglobin that has glucose stuck to it. Hemoglobin lives inside red blood cells. Glucose attaches slowly and it does not come off. So the number depends on two things, not one: how...

21 days ago • 2 min read